Monday, October 28, 2013

Text Set: Latin Verbs

Text Set: Latin Verbs Forms & Translations

1. Wheelock’s Latin
Reading Level: 9.9
Description: Wheelock is one of the most well-known and comprehensive introductory texts for Latin. It introduces Latin from the very first day of instruction (what is an inflected language? what alphabet does Latin use?) through some of the most complex forms in Latin. (Re: subjunctive mood, the gerund and gerundive, ablative case’s never-ending uses.) The reading level may be slightly above some students’ comfort level, although Latin is naturally a grammar-heavy language, and Wheelock does an excellent job of making the language accessible.
Rationale: Wheelock has the advantage of being comprehensive, well-written, well-known, and cheap. (Older editions are readily available for $20 or less.) Websites and texts with additional resources are easy to find—I own a book of translation passages written to accompany it. The book itself is an excellent source for alternate explanations of grammar points and alternate exercises.

2. Allen & Greenough’s New Latin Grammar
Reading Level: 12.7
Description: If Wheelock is the regular student’s go-to book for an explanation, then Allen & Greenough is the reference guide of the dedicated student for those esoteric and tricky forms. A&G functions much like the Harbrace does in English classrooms: it is a reference guide for any grammar point in the language, and therefore tends to read like a college professor’s lecture.
Rationale: A&G is not a casual resource which I see low level students using often, but it is valuable for upper level students as they learn about more complex uses of verbs (re: subjunctive mood), and especially for students in Latin IV and V, who are reading authentic Latin and will encounter all manner of constructions which may or may not have been explicitly taught.

3. The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Learning Latin
Reading Level: 7.4
Description: Straightforward and accessible, this guide to Latin is written precisely for someone who knows nothing about languages or complex grammar, but still wants to learn Latin. It has simplified explanations, handy charts, and intuitive organization—at least to someone who does not already know Latin.
Rationale: It is far more immediately accessible to students than some of the other texts (particularly A&G.) It includes several of the reader-friendly features we have discussed in class, like text and hint boxes, larger fonts and clear headings, and summary sections which highlight the most important features of the lesson.

4. Barron’s Foreign Language Guides: Latin Grammar
Reading Level: 8.8
Description: This is a small reference book with many pages of reference charts in the back. It has short, sometimes superficial explanations, but the charts are excellent as references. There is one with the verbs organized by the perfect stem (which can have a long vowel, an –x, an –s, a –u, or a –v), which is helpful for students memorizing the different parts of a verb.
Rationale: This book, unlike several of the others, is small enough to fit easily into a student’s already-full backpack. It can be an excellent review resource, or students can use the charts in the back to organize their knowledge of Latin. The teacher can even copy the charts as a handout for students.

5. Latin Teaching Materials at Saint Louis University (http://www.slu.edu/colleges/AS/languages/classical/latin/tchmat/grammar/vb/vbcontents.html)
Reading Level: 5.3
Description: This online resource includes grammar resources for many different subjects within Latin. Each lesson is organized into PDFs to download, and many have exercises to download as well. The explanations are short and clear, and include useful charts and diagrams.
Rationale: This resource is available for free online, so any students who have internet access at home can access it—access is not limited to one user or physical proximity, like with a book. The explanations, although short, can be a good review for students, particularly if they have taken a semester off from Latin. The exercises can also serve as a review.

6. Latin Lexicon: Word Study Tool (latinlexicon.org/word_study_tool.php)
Reading Level: 8.5
Description: This online tool allows students to type in a word – with an ending or in its dictionary format – and search it. The Lexicon will return the dictionary meaning of the word as well as the specific form, with the option for a student to add the word to an online set of flashcards. For example, “ambulavisse” would return as “ambulo, ambulare, ambulavi, ambulatus: to walk, walk about, take a walk; perfect active infinitive”.
Rationale: While this tool may encourage students to become lazy in recognizing their forms, it can also help students to learn words with irregular forms, such as “fero, ferre, tuli, latus: to bear.” These words are easy to forget until students see them often enough to remember that the irregular forms belong together as one verb. The flashcard feature is especially useful because it allows students to mark the words with which they have more trouble.

7. Verbix: Latin Verb Conjugator (http://www.verbix.com/languages/latin.shtml)
Reading Level: 5.6
Description: Verbix allows students to enter the first principal part of a verb into its search box, and then it shows an entire conjugation chart for that verb. It labels the subjunctive as the “conjunctive”, but otherwise is a very straightforward resource for reviewing verb forms.
Rationale: Latin is rife with irregular and illogical exceptions to the rules – as is any language – and so having a full verb chart is very useful, particularly when students are trying to find the differences between one form and another. This is also extremely helpful for irregular verbs.

8. A Web of Latin Verb Synopses (http://web.utk.edu/~ehsuther/synop.html)
Reading Level: 7.8
Description: This webpage allows students to type in verbs of a specific conjugation (with or without macrons) to practice making the forms. It automatically checks the student’s answers so that the student can see what he/she got correct and incorrect.
Rationale: Making forms can be very difficult, even after a student has memorized all the rules. This website allows a student to practice at home and drill him/herself in MAKING the form, not just in reading off a list of the forms. Practicing making the form helps students to remember it better than merely looking at the form.

9. The Latin Library: Latin Handouts (http://www.thelatinlibrary.com/101/)
Reading Level: 5.7
Description: This website has an extensive list of PDF handouts which students can download to review different grammar points. The handouts are brief reviews, but are suitable as a review or reference sheet for students.
Rationale: Free review and reference sheets for teachers and students!

10. Diagramming Latin Sentences (http://www2.cnr.edu/home/bmcmanus/diagraminglatin.html)
Reading Level: 10.2
Description: This website offers an easy introduction to diagramming Latin sentences, which can be valuable for understanding an inflected language. Unlike English, Latin depends on endings rather than on word order in order to understand how a word is being used in a sentence.
Rationale: While diagramming may not help all students, it can help some students to see a sentence visually deconstructed. This website offers a clear introduction to that exercise.

11. The Subjunctive Mood: Uses (http://www.dl.ket.org/latin3/grammar/Subj.htm)
Reading Level: 7.4
Description: This short website offers an introduction to the subjunctive mood, and its independent and dependent uses. There are example sentences in English to show how English uses the subjunctive mood.
Rationale: Subjunctive is one of the hardest features of Latin for students to learn, and so extra resources and explanations are always useful. This one is particularly nice because it includes examples of the subjunctive in English, which is often not discussed in Latin classes.

12. Ed Connelly: Latin (http://www.edonnelly.com/latin/)
Reading Level: 10.1
Description: A list of tools which students can use to study specific concepts of Latin, such as a verb conjugation or a noun declension.
Rationale: These tools allow students to practice their skills at home in a more interesting way than teacher-assigned worksheets. Anything which is freely accessible, repeatable, reliable, and interesting is a good resource to give to students.

13. Interactive Latin (http://www.open.ac.uk/Arts/interactiveLatin/verbRecognition.html)
Reading Level: 4.2
Description: This is a multiple-choice format quiz which asks students simple questions about verb forms, such as “Which answer is in the future tense?”
Rationale: It practices instant recognition and differentiation between forms.

14. Classics: Uses of the Latin Subjunctive (http://www.rmc.edu/academics/classics/subjunctive.aspx)
Reading Level: 0.8
Description: This page is composed almost solely of charts showing the different uses of the subjunctive in a formulaic layout. It is excellent because it shows the words which signal the different types of subjunctive clauses.
Rationale: In concert with some of the other subjunctive and verb resources, this resource is an excellent way for students to review the uses of the subjunctive.

15. Prolegomena to Latin: Understanding Our English Grammar (http://community.middlebury.edu/~harris/EngLatGrammar.html)
Reading Level: 15.5
Description: This resource, unlike several of the other resources, focuses on English grammar rather than on Latin grammar. In order for students to understand how to translate a Latin sentence or clause into English, they must understand both the Latin and the English—not the Latin alone. After all, they may be able to recognize a purpose clause, but without knowing what it is in English, that knowledge is useless.
Rationale: Students need to know how English grammar works in order to translate Latin into English.

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Weekly Reading: October 28th



1. What was the chapter about?
Fitzgerald & Graves talk about how to scaffold and differentiate instruction for ESL students. They suggest several different ways to present instruction, particularly new vocabulary. They strongly suggest breaking activities and readings into different sections so that ESL and struggling students can get at least a small amount of information out of the activity, rather than feeling overwhelmed and giving up.
Bromley points out nine facts about teaching and learning vocabulary. She strongly supports teaching students to recognize parts of words – prefixes, roots, and suffixes – as a way to decode the meaning of new and intimidating words. She also suggests teaching fewer words and practicing them orally, as using oral language is more instinctive than using written language.
2. What does this chapter tell you about teaching students?
Fitzgerald & Graves point out what I already know from my ESL placement (I’m spending several weeks each in an elementary, middle, and high school ESL classroom to become licensed in ESL): those students need a lot of support which they often do not get in their regular classroom. The same applies to struggling students. The more that you can scaffold and differentiate for those students, the more they will be able to learn.
Bromley suggests several strategies for teaching students. I especially like teaching word roots, as it is something which will help both Latin students and ESL students learn their new langauge.
3. Can this chapter be applied in your content area?
Fitzgerald & Graves give good advice at face value, but from my experience in an ESL classroom, I suspect that they have more theoretical than practical knowledge of ESL students. They forget important factors like “few ESL students will be literate in their own language,” “students from nominally the same language background may speak different dialects of that language,” “no one at your school may know their specific language and dialect,” and, most of all, “you are teaching students English, not reinforcing their desire to fall back on their native language.” Once you make allowances for those factors, however, their advice becomes applicable to both ESL students and struggling readers. After all, ESL students can often listen to and speak a language years before they can read or write it at the same level, so they share many of the same characteristics of struggling readers.
Bromley explicitly states what a lot of teachers should know, but may have forgotten (or forgotten to apply). In just one week of working with ESL students, I have seen many of these techniques, so I can vouch for their applicability and importance. This is also important in Latin, because that also teaches a language by teaching vocabulary.

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Weekly Readings: October 21st



1. What was the chapter about?
BBR chapter 5 gives several strategies for teaching students new vocabulary words. Each of those strategies comes with a description of exactly what skills the strategy will improve, how to prepare to use the strategy, and how to actually teach the strategy to students.
Tierney and Readence chapter 8 also gives several strategies for teaching students new vocabulary words. It is obvious that the two readings share an author, as several of the strategies overlap – as well as the specific examples used to explain the strategies.
2. What does this chapter tell you about teaching students?
BBR chapter 5 gives explicit, concrete directions for teaching unfamiliar academic vocabulary to students. Students do not remember words if the teacher simply tells the definition to them, but by involving them in the process of figuring out the definition, students will remember the definition much more accurately and much longer.
Tierney and Readence chapter 8 reinforces the idea that students need extra help remembering new vocabulary terms, and that involving students in the learning process helps them remember the information much longer.
3. Can this chapter be applied in your content area?
Latin teaches a lot of grammar – far more than students have learned from their English and Language Arts classes. Even with the terms which overlap with English structures, students may not understand clearly what they are or how they relate to what the students are learning. These strategies supply ways to help students work through those difficulties for themselves.
The last strategy – Levin’s Keyword Method – is something which I already use with my Latin class. I do not call it that, or use exactly that method, but I use the same general idea. Whenever my students make vocabulary cards for a new unit, I remind them to draw pictures on their cards to remind themselves of the meaning of the word. If they see the word “puella” next to a stick figure of a girl enough times, they will remember that the word means “girl”.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Weekly Reading: Oct. 14th

1. What was the chapter about?
DZ chapter 11 was all about specific strategies to use with struggling readers to help them learn to read and learn to love to read. It offered several examples of specific strategies, as well as mentioning specific teachers and books written by reading researchers.
BBR chapter 8 discusses ways to encourage critical thinking. It suggests strategies which require students to examine the texts more closely and think critically in a structured way. It also supports the students as they make these judgments, which can begin to seem personal.
2. What does this chapter tell you about teaching students?
DZ teaches that struggling readers need extra help, from readings at their level to strategies to prime their reading, to strategies to help them identify what they do not understand and remember what they have read. When students do not read well and do not understand how to read well, they will not enjoy reading, and therefore they will avoid reading. Unfortunately, this means that students will have far fewer opportunities to learn, so teachers must use these strategies to help students learn to enjoy reading.
Students cannot begin to think critically on their own. Like learning any new skill, students need scaffolding in order to grasp the basics before they can gain proficiency in using those skills. Students need these exercises which guide them through the process so that they can get accustomed to the process before they are asked to analyze a passage on their own.
3. Can this chapter be applied in your content area?
Students do not like to translate. When they first begin learning to translate, they do not understand how to translate – even the theory of it – and so anyone who is not already a strong reader becomes a very weak reader because all their problems with reading in English are magnified when they try to read in Latin, which is an inflected language (it requires endings on all nouns, adjectives, and verbs in order to understand how those words are functioning in the sentence). Understanding how to help these students is invaluable.
Latin students, particularly upper level students, are asked to analyze the culture and documents of the Romans. Caesar’s Gallic Wars are one of the main texts used in AP Latin, and it has a very unreliable narrator. When I teach that text, I want to be able to talk about how all the information about that war comes directly from Caesar, who has every incentive to make himself look better and his enemies – or political rivals – look worse. Without critical thinking skills, however, I will never be able to have this discussion with my classes.

Sunday, October 6, 2013

Weekly Reading: Oct. 7th



Tovani ch. 5-6, BBR ch. 6

1. What was the chapter about?
Give your kids a purpose for reading – don’t try to teach every scrap of info in the book/text, just focus on 1-2 really important concepts. Students need a way to take notes about their reading so that they can remember it later. Different note-taking styles work for different students, so introduce students to many examples. Also, different types of note-taking are appropriate for different types of reading: a fiction novel won’t require the same notes as a science article. The BBR chapter described specific different strategies to help students read and understand texts.
2. What does this chapter tell you about teaching students?
If kids don’t have a purpose for reading, then they’ll get frustrated and quit. You have to give them something to focus on so that they'll keep going. Make kids practice with different types of note-taking, then let them pick what works best for them. Point out the differences between the different styles and their different applications. The BBR chapter mostly focused on activities for the teacher to use in the classroom: how to develop them and how to teach them. It also described exactly which uses each strategy has.
3. Can this chapter be applied in your content area?
Giving students a purpose when translating can help because kids hate translating (largely because they’re still bad at it), and they don’t want to do it if they don’t have to. The strategies on note-taking I see being helpful in structuring culture readings about the Romans. While telling kids "read this article and talk about how the Romans are different than modern America" usually generates good answers, giving them a structure would keep the discussion going farther -- and help those few who get off-task to stay focused.